Interpersonal Violence Linked to Alcohol Consumption Trends

Alcohol is one of the most widely consumed substances globally, and its consumption is linked to numerous adverse effects on mental health, including increased aggression and a heightened risk of engaging in violent behavior. This issue extends to the realm of interpersonal violence (IV), defined as the intentional use of physical force against an individual or group. Research indicates that the likelihood of committing interpersonal violence escalates dramatically in the early stages of alcohol intoxication, following a distinct inverted U-shaped curve (Kilian et al., 2024). Individual traits, such as behavioral control, inhibition, social learning, and attentional processes, have all been shown to influence the propensity for violent actions while under the influence (Sontate et al., 2021). However, there remains a significant gap in understanding the experiences of victims subjected to violence stemming from alcohol consumption, as well as the global prevalence of such experiences.

The recent systematic review and modeling study by Kilian et al. (2024) addresses this critical gap in existing literature by examining the prevalence of various forms of interpersonal violence—including emotional, physical, sexual, and intimate partner violence—that occur as a direct result of alcohol use by perpetrators. This research spans national, regional, and international levels, focusing specifically on data collected in 2019.

Comprehensive Research Methods for Understanding Alcohol-Related Violence

The research team conducted a thorough pre-registered international literature review, meticulously searching through well-established databases such as PubMed, Web of Science, Medline, PsycInfo, and Embase. Inclusion criteria required studies to be original quantitative research that primarily involved adult samples from the general population, specifically examining interpersonal violence related to others’ alcohol consumption, while also reporting prevalence data. To ensure quality and reliability, the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale was employed to evaluate the risk of bias within the studies analyzed.

Only unique datasets with the largest sample sizes and prevalence figures were considered. Data reported as combined gender were excluded if specific estimates based on sex or gender were available. For studies that only provided prevalence rates among alcohol users, estimates for the total population were calculated using a formula that incorporated study data alongside conservative estimates of relative risk drawn from existing literature. To predict the past-year prevalence of both emotional and physical violence, fractional response regression models were utilized, while random-effects meta-regression models were employed to aggregate observed prevalence rates for sexual and intimate partner violence.

Key Findings on Violence Related to Alcohol Consumption

The comprehensive search process yielded a total of 13,835 studies, of which 50 met the criteria for inclusion in the final analysis. These studies collectively represented approximately 830,000 individuals spanning 61 different countries, providing a broad perspective on the issue.

Insights into Physical Violence Associated with Alcohol Use

The prediction model for physical violence indicated that around 5.3% of men and 3.3% of women in the High-Income region reported experiencing this type of violence. The prevalence rates exhibited considerable variation across different countries; for instance, in Malta, the estimated rates were 3.6% for men and 2.2% for women, while in Portugal, these figures increased to 6.8% for men and 4.2% for women. Within the broader region encompassing Central Europe, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia, the prevalence was similar, with 5.4% of men and 3.3% of women indicating experiences of physical violence attributed to others’ drinking. Azerbaijan recorded the lowest predicted rates at 1.1% for men and 0.7% for women, in stark contrast to Moldova, where rates peaked at 9.5% for men and 5.9% for women.

In regions not covered by the modeling efforts, observed data unveiled a broader spectrum of experiences; for example, in Latin America and the Caribbean, prevalence rates for physical violence varied significantly, ranging from 6.0% to 20.7% among men, and from 0.8% to 3.8% among women across countries such as Belize, Brazil, and Peru. South Asia, especially in India, showed even more alarming figures, with prevalence rates ranging from 9.3% to 36.3% for men and approximately 32.7% for women. In Southeast Asia, East Asia, and Oceania, physical violence rates fluctuated between 0.9% to 24.4% among men and 0.2% to 22.4% among women, depending on the specific country.

Prevalence of Emotional Violence Linked to Alcohol Consumption

The estimated prevalence of emotional violence in the High-Income region was approximately 16.8%, with Malta reporting the lowest estimates at 12.2% and Portugal the highest at 24.0%. In Central Europe, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia, Armenia exhibited a striking prevalence of emotional violence estimated at 34.4%, while Azerbaijan displayed the lowest estimate at 17.8%. Regarding the observed lifetime prevalence in regions not included in the model, Brazil reported a prevalence of 7.0%, while India indicated alarming past-year rates of 41.5% for men and 38.0% for women.

Notably, one in four adults in Central Europe, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia experienced emotional violence due to others’ drinking, with one in six adults affected in High-Income regions, underscoring the widespread impact of such violence.

Sexual Violence Statistics in Relation to Alcohol Consumption

The study found that the pooled prevalence for sexual violence was 1.3% among men and 3.4% among women, highlighting a concerning trend where women are significantly more likely to experience this type of violence compared to men.

Understanding Intimate Partner Violence Related to Alcohol Use

In terms of intimate partner violence, estimates showed that emotional violence had a prevalence of 2.7%, while physical and sexual violence were markedly lower, at 0.6% and 0.4% respectively. This indicates that emotional abuse is significantly more prevalent when compared to other forms of intimate partner violence associated with alcohol consumption.

Significant Insights on Alcohol-Related Violence

This groundbreaking study represents the first effort to estimate the national and regional prevalence of interpersonal violence stemming from others’ alcohol consumption. Findings reveal that in 2019, approximately one in four adults (25%) in Central Europe, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia, along with one in six individuals (17%) in High-Income regions, suffered from emotional violence due to others’ drinking.

Physical violence was reported less frequently, affecting 5% of men and 3% of women across the investigated regions.

Sexual violence and intimate partner violence related to alcohol were less common overall, although these rates varied widely across the studies examined.

Gender disparities were evident, with men more likely to encounter physical violence and women facing a higher risk of sexual violence, indicating a significant need for targeted interventions.

Evaluating Strengths and Limitations of the Study

The research conducted by Kilian and colleagues stands out as a comprehensive and methodologically sound investigation, presenting a unique perspective on the harms associated with alcohol, particularly focusing on the victims rather than perpetrators.

The study adhered to pre-registration protocols and followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, which are vital indicators of transparency and reproducibility in research. The authors have been forthright in acknowledging inherent limitations, such as the absence of data from several countries (including significant regions in Asia and Africa), the potential biases of self-reported data, the data models employed, and the cultural differences that influence perceptions surrounding alcohol-related harms. While these challenges are likely unavoidable in global self-report surveys, they do not diminish the considerable contribution of this research to the field.

Furthermore, despite the inclusion of various aspects of alcohol-induced interpersonal violence, questions arise about the appropriateness of all components for this research design. For instance, physical violence may be more readily reported compared to other types of violence, possibly due to its public nature or the need for police intervention, whereas sexual violence or intimate partner violence may occur out of sight and remain underreported. This discrepancy may be reflected in the limited number of studies included for intimate partner violence (10 studies) and sexual violence (11 studies). Intuitively, it can be argued that this may not accurately represent the global prevalence of these issues. Nonetheless, the authors do not claim comprehensive representation, but it does prompt further investigation into the variances in types of interpersonal violence and the most suitable study designs to explore these phenomena.

Additionally, the study appeared to focus primarily on binary sex data, possibly to streamline the scope of the analysis. However, it is crucial to consider that among sexual minorities, including transgender individuals, there may be an increased risk of experiencing alcohol-related harms and violence (Coulter et al., 2016), which should not be overlooked in future research endeavors.

Practical Implications of the Findings on Alcohol-Related Violence

This research serves as a crucial foundation for expanding discussions surrounding the harms of alcohol to encompass the experiences of victims affected by others’ alcohol use. A significant takeaway is the concerning prevalence of interpersonal violence linked to alcohol consumption, particularly noted in European regions, which affects a substantial number of individuals. The World Health Organization emphasizes that there is no entirely safe level of alcohol consumption, and the findings from this study reinforce this critical understanding. While harm reduction strategies and educational initiatives are undoubtedly beneficial, the results provoke questions about the necessity for stricter regulations on alcohol, as many nations rely primarily on age restrictions as their main regulatory measure. Numerous substances that are illegal or tightly controlled result in fewer adverse outcomes than alcohol does. Moreover, the observed gender disparities, including the higher frequency of men as perpetrators and the differences in violence types faced by men and women, indicate that harm reduction policies could be enhanced through more tailored approaches. Previous community-based efforts have shown limited effectiveness in mitigating alcohol-related harms, as highlighted in a previous Mental Elf blog (Clarke 2018). Thus, expanding research to identify personal characteristics of both victims and perpetrators may be instrumental in successfully preventing alcohol-related violence.

Disclosures and Interests of the Researcher

Nora is currently pursuing her PhD in the field of addiction studies, focusing on the intricacies of alcohol-related harms and their implications.

Essential References for Further Reading

Primary Research Article

Kilian, C., Klinger, S., Manthey, J., Rehm, J., Huckle, T., & Probst, C. (2024). National and regional prevalence of interpersonal violence from others’ alcohol use: a systematic review and modelling study. The Lancet Regional Health Europe, 40, 100905.

Additional References

Clarke, N. (2018). Community action has little impact on harms from alcohol use disorder. The Mental Elf. 9^thOctober 2018.

Coulter, R. W., Blosnich, J. R., Bukowski, L. A., Herrick, A. L., Siconolfi, D. E., & Stall, R. D. (2015). Differences in alcohol use and alcohol-related problems between transgender- and nontransgender-identified young adults. Drug and alcohol dependence, 154, 251–259.

Sontate, K. V., Rahim Kamaluddin, M., Naina Mohamed, I., Mohamed, R. M. P., Shaikh, M. F., Kamal, H., & Kumar, J. (2021). Alcohol, Aggression, and Violence: From Public Health to Neuroscience. Frontiers in psychology, 12, 699726.

Image Credits